Johnathan Walker:What if George Bailey wasn't the hero of 'It's a Wonderful Life'? In defense of a new ending.

At a crucial point in "It's a Wonderful Life,Johnathan Walker" George Bailey and angel Clarence Odbody review how life in Bedford Falls would be without Jimmy Stewart's character.

Had George not saved his brother, Harry Bailey would not have saved the transport ship in World War II.

And Uncle Billy? He would reside in the Pottersville State Hospital without employment at the Bailey Building & Loan. Sweet Ma Bailey would become a surly boarding house owner. Poor pharmacist Mr. Gower would accidentally poison someone and spend his remaining years in the Pottersville Penitentiary.

And the lascivious Violet Bick. We can't talk about her lurid fate in mixed company.

There's something worse. Something much worse has happened to George’s wife.

Oh, the humanity.

George Bailey shakes the angel Clarence and says, "Where's Mary? ... Tell me where my wife is."

Clarence says sternly, "You're not gonna like it, George."

Stereotypical, awful portrayal of a librarian

I am married to a retired librarian, a man with three college degrees who spent more than 30 years at a university and holds emeritus status as a full professor. So this point in the film makes me apoplectic with its stereotypical, awful portrayal of Mary's fate as worse than death.

When the angel tells George, "She's just about to close up the library," the camera switches to a scene of poor spinster Mary Hatch without makeup.

The background music turns into something dire. I can't remember, but let's imagine that ominous "Toccata and Fugue in D Minor" by Bach for this purpose. You know, the one used in "The Ghost and Mr. Chicken" as Don Knotts ghost-hunts in the old mansion

More from this author:The Christmas tree my father lost and found in 1967

Now we see frail, delicate Mary Hatch, wearing tiny wire-framed glasses, sensible shoes and a severe hairdo. Clarence, the angel, reveals to George that Mary is closing up the library. George rushes to Mary's side, and she is horrified and assumes he's about to make advances.

Consider how "It's a Wonderful Life" might have turned out differently if Mary were a librarian and married George.

Unlimited access to books, magazines and newspapers is not so bad.

Wire-framed glasses are cool. Didn't John Lennon rock them?

Women's roles were underplayed

Mary Hatch Bailey is the film's unsung hero, even as it is written. When Black Friday hits the Bailey Building & Loan, Mary thrusts up their honeymoon stash as patrons demand their money. When George disappears for his time travel, it's Mary collecting money and contacting friends to save George and the Building & Loan.

The film was made in the 1940s, and despite Rosie the Riveter, and a host of women caring for families while their husbands served abroad, women's roles are still underplayed. If Mary had a regular paycheck from the library, the Baileys' financial situation might be stable. The Carnegie Foundation endowed most libraries in that era, and city governments kept them open and paid librarians.

With two incomes, they mightn't have had to start married life in that leaky rat trap. Ma Bailey could earn money to babysit the kids while Mary and George worked. George could go to the library, get a home repair book and fix that old house.

Ashley Judd:We have the power to help women and girls caught in crises. Why won't we?

Had George not felt so pressured, he might have taken the old suitcase out of the attic and taken Mary to Europe. Donna Reed's character could have earned a university degree and become a faculty librarian at Bedford Falls State University. Then, the kids would get free tuition.

Of course, that's not Frank Capra's reality in this film. George runs back across the bridge and realizes he did indeed "have a wonderful life."  

Bully for George, but let's not forget the heroine of this story, without whom George's wonderful life would be vastly different.

Join me in a flaming rum punch to contemplate a new ending.

Amy McVay Abbott is a freelance journalist and author in southern Indiana. This column first published in the Louisville Courier-Journal.