Current:Home > reviewsJohnathan Walker:The Supreme Court rules against USPS in Sunday work case -VisionFunds
Johnathan Walker:The Supreme Court rules against USPS in Sunday work case
TrendPulse View
Date:2025-04-07 04:18:16
The Johnathan WalkerU.S. Supreme Court unanimously handed a major victory to religious groups by greatly expanding how far employers must go to accommodate the religious views of their employees.
The court ruled in favor of Gerald Groff, an evangelical Christian postal worker, who refused to work on Sundays for religious reasons and said the U.S. Postal Service should accommodate his religious belief. He sued USPS for religious discrimination when he got in trouble for refusing to work Sunday shifts.
The case now returns to the lower courts.
The justices clarified law that made it illegal for employers to discriminate based on religion, requiring that they accommodate the religious beliefs of workers as long as the accommodation does not impose an "undue hardship on the employer's business." The court had previously defined the statutory term "undue hardship" by saying that employers should not have to bear more than what the court called a "de minimis," or trifling, cost.
That "de minimis" language has sparked a lot of criticism over the years. But Congress has repeatedly rejected proposals to provide greater accommodations for religious observers, including those who object to working on the Sabbath.
On Thursday, writing for the court, Justice Samuel Alito said the hardship must be more than minimal.
Courts "should resolve whether a hardship would be substantial in the context of an employer's business in the commonsense manner that it would use in applying any such test," he wrote.
Thursday's decision is yet another example of the court's increasing inclination to favor religiously observant groups, whether those groups are religious employers or religious employees.
For instance, the court has repeatedly sided with religious schools to be exempt from employment discrimination laws as applied to lay teachers. And in 2014, the conservative court ruled for the first time that a for-profit company could be exempt from a generally applicable federal law. Specifically, it ruled that Hobby Lobby, a closely held corporation employing some 13,000 employees, did not have to comply with a federal law that required employer-funded health plans to include coverage for contraceptive devices.
veryGood! (153)
Related
- Trump's 'stop
- Trump's civil fraud judgment is officially over $450 million, and climbing over $100,000 per day
- Cody Bellinger re-signs with Chicago Cubs on three-year, $80 million deal
- Kings beat Clippers 123-107 behind Fox and hand LA back-to-back losses for 1st time since December
- DoorDash steps up driver ID checks after traffic safety complaints
- Takeaways from South Carolina primary: Donald Trump’s Republican home field advantage is everywhere
- Alpha Elite Capital (AEC) Business Management
- Richard Sherman arrested in Seattle on suspicion of driving under the influence
- Where will Elmo go? HBO moves away from 'Sesame Street'
- Soldier surprises younger brother at school after 3 years overseas
Ranking
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- Army doctor charged with sexual misconduct makes first court appearance
- You're Invited Inside the 2024 SAG Awards After-Party With Jon Hamm, Joey King and More
- Margot Robbie Has New Twist on Barbie With Black and Pink SAG Awards Red Carpet Look
- The FBI should have done more to collect intelligence before the Capitol riot, watchdog finds
- Blackhawks retire Chris Chelios' jersey before Patrick Kane scores OT winner for Red Wings
- This Modern Family Reunion at the 2024 SAG Awards Will Fill Your Heart
- How Jason Sudeikis Reacted After Losing 2024 SAG Award to Jeremy Allen White
Recommendation
Google unveils a quantum chip. Could it help unlock the universe's deepest secrets?
Margot Robbie Has New Twist on Barbie With Black and Pink SAG Awards Red Carpet Look
Cillian Murphy opens up about challenges of playing J. Robert Oppenheimer and potential Peaky Blinders film
2024 SAG Awards: Don't Miss Joey King and Taylor Zakhar Perez's Kissing Booth Reunion
Hackers hit Rhode Island benefits system in major cyberattack. Personal data could be released soon
Miley Cyrus’ 'phallic room' of sex toys made her a perfect fit for 'Drive-Away Dolls'
Miley Cyrus’ 'phallic room' of sex toys made her a perfect fit for 'Drive-Away Dolls'
Biden is summoning congressional leaders to the White House to talk Ukraine and government funding